"World Cinema: Israel"

My book, "World Cinema: Israel" (originally published in 1996) is available from Amazon on "Kindle", with an in-depth chapter comparing and analyzing internationally acclaimed Israeli films up to 2010.

Want to see some of the best films of recent years? Just scroll down to "best films" to find listings of my recommendations.


Friday, March 9, 2018

The Dysfunctional Family

A new Israeli feature film opened this week at movie theaters in Israel – Montana, directed by Limor Shmila -- a film about a dysfunctional family.

When Effi’s grandfather dies suddenly, she goes to visit her family in Acco.  There, she visits her grandmother and her middle-aged aunt.  Her uncle lives nearby.  Years ago, her mother took Effi away suddenly, cut off relations with her family and moved to France. We don’t know why, but it becomes suddenly so clear at the end of the film.

Here is your best abusive and cheating love triangle -- Effi’s uncle, a policeman, is a pervert, abusing the young daughter of his friend.  The friend is carrying on with Effi’s aunt.  Just to round things out, Effi begins an affair with the friend’s wife.  In brief, everyone is cheating on everyone.

Although Effi was a compelling character, the film was a disappointment because it had no cinematic sophistication and little complexity of plot.

Tuesday, March 6, 2018

Between a Rock and a Hard Place

Since shortly after the Six-Day War of 1967, when Israel annexed East Jerusalem, the residents of East Jerusalem have been residents of Israel, but not citizens. As residents, all of their personal status matters must be registered via the Israeli Ministry of the Interior in East Jerusalem.

An award-winning and compelling documentary film by Amir Har-Gil (an Israeli - Jew) and Isfahan Bahaloul (an Israeli - Muslim), Jerusalem in Line, tackles the difficult subject of how these residents have been humiliated and mistreated by this ministry, and how their basic human rights have been denied.    

People go to the Ministry of Interior offices to register births and marriages, and to apply for passports -- in this case actually laissez-passez documents since the Palestinians of East Jerusalem are not able to receive passports since they are not considered citizens of Israel. The applicants were forced to wait on long lines in the hot sun, were treated poorly when they got inside, and their requests were often denied without serious investigation into the complications and implications of each case.

The film, which is premiering this month at the Cinema Village in New York City, as part of the Socially Relevant Film Festival, follows three stories of people who have been forced to fight on-going battles with the Ministry of Interior due to serious infringements of their rights.  One story is about a 12-year-old girl who loses her health insurance since her resident status had been revoked for no apparent reason.  Another is the story of a Palestinian man whose residence in an East Jerusalem neighborhood was misconstrued to be across the border in the West Bank, and as a result, he lost his resident status meaning no social security, no disability benefits, and no health coverage.  The fact that he paid his annual municipal taxes (even though they claimed he didn’t live in Jerusalem) and the fact that he had had medical coverage all his life didn’t change matters.  Indeed, his need for dialysis three times a week only made his case more severe.  A third story was about a man whose house was demolished by bulldozers sent by the city, but he was continuously being billed for city taxes on this same house! 

Using the technique of a story-teller who sits outside the Ministry of the Interior in East Jerusalem, the filmmakers are able to relate these stories, and more, with charm, compassion and humanity – virtues that should be requirements to become bureaucrats of the government of Israel! 

Jerusalem in Line is a documentary film (63 minutes), available directly from Amir Har-Gil.  Check out his website.

Wednesday, January 31, 2018

Shelter by award-winning director Eran Riklis

Shelter (מסתור) is a thriller by Eran Riklis, one of Israel’s greatest filmmakers, known for his many prize-winning films including Syrian Bride, The Lemon Tree, Cup Final, The Human Resources Manager, and Dancing Arabs. 

As in The Lemon Tree, here, in Shelter, he tackles the subject of relationships between women across the divide, showing the compassion and humanity of the “other.”  But the films are so different!

In this film, Nomi is sent on a mission by the Mossad to babysit Mona, a Lebanese informer, hidden in Germany, having just undergone extensive plastic surgery in preparation for her promised new life in Canada.  It seems like a simple mission, but nothing is simple when the Mossad is involved.
An adaption of Shulamit Hareven’s story The Link, the film combines two genres. One is a psychological study of two women and how the relationship between them intensifies as they are confined to an apartment in Hamburg. Their personal stories are told through flashbacks as they confide in each other.  Nomi has spent the last two years stricken with grief as she has been mourning her husband who was killed by a bullet meant for her. Now, she wants to have the baby that she never had when her husband was alive.  Mona, previously the lover of the head of Hezbollah in Lebanon, is feeling cooped up, fearful for her own personal well-being and her future, and crazy with worry about her 8-year-old son who is hidden in a monastery in Lebanon. Both women are struggling with issues of identity, hiding who they are, trying on wigs, wondering who and where they will be when all of this is over.

The film is also a thriller about international espionage and intrigue.  Tension mounts as Nomi realizes that she is being watched, as the Hezbollah are searching for Mona who has betrayed them, and as the Germans and the Americans are hoping to use Mona as a pawn in their game of buying favors with Iran against Hezbollah.

I enjoy thrillers, but I don’t usually find them so compelling! This film is a particularly captivating and powerful story about two women, their fears and their worries, wonderfully performed and well-crafted, filled with tension and twists and turns.  It seems that betrayal is the name of the game.  And loyalty brings redemption.

Shelter is available from Menemsha Films.

Tuesday, January 16, 2018

New Holocaust Film

Three new Israeli feature films opened this week in Jerusalem.  I chose first to go see The Testament (העדות), directed by Amichai Greenberg, because the story sounded compelling.  A Holocaust story, it is about a modern-day investigation of an Austrian cover-up of a massacre of Jewish laborers, near the end of the war.  The film is shot both in Jerusalem and in Austria, which provides an authentic and realistic feeling to the historical story. 

Joel, the chief investigator, is an ultra-orthodox Holocaust scholar who becomes obsessed with the investigation.  During the course of his work, while he is interviewing witnesses, he stumbles upon a woman who coincidentally knew his parents, back in the Ghetto.  She gives him an old photo which leads him to dig deeper into his family’s past and to uncover a shocking discovery. This is a complex story and the news, which is tragic and shameful for him, causes him to question his own identity. 

I was disappointed in the portrayal of the main character, the Holocaust scholar, who is so obsessed with his work, that he becomes a one-dimensional character.  He is without charm, doesn’t show any warmth to his colleagues or his family members, and cannot wrap his head around the shocking news which brings him to cruelly confront his own aging mother.

The Testament portrays a fascinating slice of history, but it is a disappointing film.  

Friday, January 5, 2018

Children's Literature

One Last Bedtime Story, a television documentary series by Anat Zeltser and Modi Bar-On, is a new and fascinating TV series about children’s literature.  I have only had a chance to preview the first episode, but if it is a sign of what is to come, we are in for a most compelling series. 

The first episode, which offers a discussion of issues of language, opens with a wonderful reading by well-known Israeli authors of Natan Alterman’s children’s poem, “The Overcoat.”  In a discussion of the early writers of children’s literature, we encounter iconic writers such as Alterman, Haim N. Bialik, Leah Goldberg, Avraham Shlonsky, Meir Shalev, and others.  We learn about the butterfly, which is a “living flower” according to Bialik.  Did you know that the “see saw” rhyme that we sing when our children are swinging and playing was written by Bialik? 

We are shown illustrations by the early gifted illustrator who worked with Bialik, Tom Seidann-Freud, a female pioneer in the field. In addition to illustrators, we meet singers and authors such as Meir Shalev, Shira Geffen, Etgar Keret, David Grossman, and more, all discussing early writers of Hebrew-language children’s literature. We learn about Levin Kipnis who created so many children’s folk songs, and Leah Goldberg who wrote children’s poems for “Davar for Children” which was a publication of the “Davar” newspaper. 

What happened to the unique ways that modern Hebrew was once spoken?  The unique accents have given way to a melting pot of modern-day spoken Hebrew.  Yehudit Ravitz doesn’t see any conflict in the fact that she loves to hear the songs of Umm Kulthum (a great Egyptian female singer of Eastern music) and also read Agnon.  All of these elements have come together to form who we are.
There are fascinating issues discussed – the need for the “invention” of children’s literature in Hebrew where it never existed before; how to deal with the parents’ generation of immigrants who had to be taught the language; the changing pronunciation over the decades; whether to write on the level of the children, or trusting them to understand, without being patronizing or, on the other hand, too sophisticated.

One Last Bedtime Story, produced for YES TV, is available from Maya Weinberg mayafilmfest@gmail.com. Currently, only the first episode (65 minutes) is available with English subtitles – which, by the way, were amazingly poetic.  Check out the upcoming screenings at the Tel Aviv Cinematheque this month!

Monday, January 1, 2018

Best Films of 2017

Here is my list of "best films". 
Since all of these films have been reviewed on this blog, you can check out the hot links for in-depth reviews!
Happy New Year!

Best Films of 2017

          Everything is Broken Up and Dances, starring and directed by Nony Geffen - a difficult film about a young man suffering from PTSD, about living with war and getting on with life.

In Between (Bar Bahar) -- Maysaloun Hamoud -- a compelling story about three Palestinian Israeli women, who are caught between their traditional society and the allure of the independent and open lifestyle of Tel Aviv.

An Israeli Love StoryDan Wolman - a tragic, yet overwhelmingly compelling story, set during the tumultuous period of the end of the British Mandate. 

The Cakemaker Ofir Raul Graizer -  a surprisingly tender romantic story about a German man who runs a coffee shop in Berlin. 

Foxtrot  - Samuel Maoz --  a brilliant and provocative prize-winning film which offers a shocking and effective cinematic criticism of the military establishment.

LongingSavi Gabizon – a touching story of family and bereavement.  

Maktub Oded Raz – a sentimental story about good deeds and helping make people’s wishes come true, starring two wonderfully ethnic characters!

Norman, The Moderate Rise and Tragic Fall of a New York Fixer -- Joseph Cedar - starring Lior Ashkenazi and Richard Gere - a hard-hitting look at the relationship between American Jewry and the political leadership of Israel. 

Scaffolding - Matan Yair –  a story about Israeli high school kids who have been categorized as illiterate and also about a teacher who succeeds in making a difference in the lives of these kids.

       And the TV series –

Fauda -- Assaf Bernstein – an action series about an elite unit doing undercover work in the West Bank.  

Wednesday, November 29, 2017

A Disappointing Film

There are lots of good Israeli films playing in the movie theaters in Jerusalem right now.  I highly recommend Foxtrot, Scaffolding, Longing and Maktub – all of which have been reviewed previously on this blog. 

There is one more playing right now – The Burglar (הפורצת) by Hagar Ben-Asher -- about a teenage girl, living in Arad, who discovers that her mother has suddenly left her. The girl begins to break into apartments to obtain money in order to pay the rent and to buy a motor scooter.  Things become weird when she uses the money to pay for a hotel room by the Dead Sea in order to attract a visiting German geologist.  It is too bad that the film suffers from a lack of depth and little character development, and therefore I would not put this on my list of recommended films.